NESS 2019: 14th Nordic Environmental Social Science Conference: Social Science in Our time

9-11.6. 2019, Luleå, Norrbotten, Sweden.

Nordic Environmental Social Science (NESS) Conference, “Social Sciences in our Time”, June 2019. Luleå University of Technology, Sweden. 

Workshop: Opportunities and Challenges for the Circular Economy. Coordinators: Heikki Huilaja & Jerry Blomberg

Teemu Loikkanen

Paper: Citizenship in waste economy

With a rental car, Heikki drove us through Aavasaksa to take Veera aboard from the riverbanks where she was on a fishing holiday with her family. The unpredictability of the northern summer was upon us once again, as the weekend started with a 30 degrees Celsius warmth, but when we arrived it was closer to 10 and the rain was pouring. Luleå seemed like a beautiful city, surprisingly close to Rovaniemi, as there were only around 320 kilometres between the two. NESS 2019 conference begun with a welcoming ceremony at the Vetenskaphuset (House of Science).

Our working group, “Opportunities and Challenges for the Circular Economy” gathered on the first session after the first keynote -speech. Ann-Kristin Bergqvist and Magnus Lindmark presented their paper, a historical analysis of the Swedish recycling industry, where successful implementations of incarceration plants have made them to import big amounts of wastes from other countries and in that way promoted the economic aspects of waste management.

Angela Kedatiene participated with her paper to the conversation about the relationship of GDP-growth and “green“ policies. The big question for EUs Circular Economy is, are the policies for “green growth” and environmental betterments compatible? If not, which one is the CE actually promoting first, and foremost?

Jacob Hasselbalchs paper concentrated on the institutional history of EUs plastic strategy, showing that many original Circular Economy policies are at present placed under the umbrella of resource efficiency. Hassebalch stated that the Circular Economy has become a new wording of previously used term “sustainable development” and that the European Commission is attempting to sell the idea to the producers by emphasizing the business opportunities.

Jay Sterling Gregg presented a paper concentrating on aquaponics, a method in which fish are grown in a way that their excrements can be used in vegetable farming. It is still highly speculative and unsure, is it possible to create commercial aquaponics -systems in a larger scale fish and vegetable production.

Antti Belinskij was asking on his paper about the regulations and governance of nutrient loading in agriculture. The Baltic Sea has been suffering from agricultural nutrient loading, and recent decades have changed the formation of Finnish agriculture significantly, as we have transferred to more concentrated larger units. There is a need to reconfigure how to govern these emissions and diminish the amounts of leakage.

Erkki-Jussi Nylen continued on the next day with a similar subject. His paper concentrated on the recycling of nutrients as a conceptual innovation. In Circular Economy, nitrogen and phosphorus should be somehow recycled to use again, but it is not a simple process.

I presented our paper concentrating on the empirical part, based on my Master’s Thesis. In waste citizenship, the responsibility is individualized. The citizens are turned to resource producers against their will and without personal benefits. Duties and obligations are placed on them. There were many good comments, for example one by Jacob Hasselbalch. He stated that if the idea of CE is sold to producers as a business opportunity, and the duties and obligations are placed on the citizens, what if it would be the other way: Citizens would gain money from recycling and duties and obligations would be placed on the producers? That is a really good question for the policy makers.

Finally, Linda Wårell presented a paper on the policies implemented in Sweden in order to reach sustainable transportation. Regional effects vary, as the repercussions of these policies are worse in smaller municipalities, where public transportation or electric cars are not suitable options.

We thank everyone involved in the organization of NESS 2019! The conference was an insightful journey to different disciplines’ views on environmental social sciences.



pablo (9).png

Sociology days 28-29.3.2019: Various Faces of Inequality

University of Turku & Åbo Akademi

Sociology Days, “Various Faces of Inequality”, March 2018. University of Turku, Finland.

Teemu Loikkanen

Paper: Jätekansalaisuus kiertotaloudessa (Waste Citizenship in Circular Economy)

Veera Kinnunen

Paper: Jätekapinalliset – maailma muuttuu ämpäri kerrallaan. (Waste rebels – the world changes bucket at a time)

Workshop: Jäteyhteiskunta (Waste Society). Coordinators: Heikki Huilaja & Jarno Valkonen

Waste is a central and visible part of society, mundane life, economy and work. Waste is something we produce, sort, avoid, recycle, transport, manage, sell, tax, spread and mill. It burdens, takes resources and time; we live with it, share space and landscape; it connects and separates, produces classifications and social order. At the same time, waste itself is a resource and a source of value creation. Regardless, waste appears, paradoxically, as visible invisible in society: matter which presence and accumulation everyone is aware of, but which we want to clean out of sight. However, waste cannot be fully disposed, only transformed to something else. Working group addresses this inevitable surplus and excess of our action and society. How do we live together with surplus and excess, in what ways are they confined and defined, what is rejected? What kind of processes turn things into rubbish and waste? How about ownership of waste? What can we do with our waste, and how to live with it? How does production and consumption define in relation to waste? If we take seriously the fundamental role of waste in construction of society, how does it appear? Waste society -working group welcomes everyone interested in waste, society, society’s materiality, consumption, objects and matter.

Torstai 28.3.2019 klo. 15:00–18:00
Åbo Akademi, ASA-huset, Athena (B311)

Elina Matilainen: Ruokahävikin arvottaminen hävikkiravintolan käytännöissä

Lena Näre & Elina Paju: Jätetyt ja jätteet – turvapaikanhakijat jäteyhteiskunnassa

Teemu Loikkanen: Jätekansalaisuus kiertotaloudessa

Taru Lehtokunnas, Malla Mattila, Nina Mesiranta & Elina Närvänen: Ruokaa vai roskaa:  Kotien ruokaylijäämäkäytännöt eettisen toimijuuden rakentamisena

Ville Savolainen & Olli Pyyhtinen: Näkymättömyyden arvottaminen ja jätevirtojen synnyttäminen hotellisiivouksessa

Perjantai 29.3.2019 klo. 9:00–11:00
Åbo Akademi, ASA-huset, Athena (B311)

Turo-Kimmo Lehtonen & Olli Pyyhtinen: Dyykkaaminen taloudellisena käytäntönä

Veera Kinnunen: Jätekapinalliset – maailma muuttuu ämpäri kerrallaan

Antti Saloniemi & Antti Wallin: Kemianteollisuuden jälkeiset jäämät

Liia Raippalinna: ”Turhaa tuhlausta”? Hävikkiongelma ja sen ratkaisut mediadiskurssissa

Notes from the workshop:

Waste Society -workshop at Sociology Days 2019 in Turku, induced in total nine presentations, as one had to cancel due to illness. There were various topics regarding waste, although different viewpoints on food waste were present in most of the presentations.

Food waste -related topics were approached, first, through the practices of a restaurant, serving food made strictly from otherwise wasted items, second, the media discourses of food waste, and third, as a way of building ethical agency in households. The values of waste fluctuate: for example, the restaurant, which offers products made from food otherwise wasted, transforms the category of waste to something positive by marketing them to consumers as environmentally friendly. Media discourses push the responsibility of diminishing food waste to the households. Similarly, concerning the citizenship of waste, duties and obligations define it. Vice Versa, the rights of a waste-citizen are scarce: right to perform a duty, in this case to recycle, is a fundamental right of a citizen of waste.

Another way of battling food waste is dumpster diving. It creates an economics of its own, although it still in many ways attaches to the common economic system. There are also novel approaches for households to combat their food waste: The Bokashi -method fundamentally changes the households’ relationship with waste management. Waste is also a part of various professions – hotels are places that deal with waste and cleanliness daily. The specific instructions for cleaners about how to perform their job and the collection of waste reveal multiple things of our relationship to waste. Things left behind can become waste, including whole lives in the processes of asylum seekers moving to Finland – on many occasions to wastelands, otherwise out of use. Finally, factory closings create specific problems regarding waste – chemistry plants are wasteful already in operation, but when they are closed, it might form even larger problems.


pablo (10)

YHYS Colloquium at University of Lapland 22.-23.11.2018

YHYS Colloquium 2018: NatureCultures, University of Lapland 22.-23.11.2018. 

Johanna Saariniemi

Zero waste life style as a contribution to circular economy

Veera Kinnunen

Workshop: Probiotic living in compromised times (Coordinators: Veera Kinnunen & Salla Sariola)

Paper: Bokashi – making probiotic waste management possible?

Heikki Huilaja

Session: Living with waste: exploring how waste shapes/ is shaped by contemporary societies. (Coordinators: Heikki Huilaja and Johanna Saariniemi)

Paper: Opening words and introduction to “The Waste Society: Living with Material Overflows” project. Heikki Huilaja.

Professor Laura Watts, University of Edinburgh gave a Keynote presentation: “NatureCultureElectric: Going on together with energy”. Research Assistant Teemu Loikkanen interviewed her in behalf of Versus magazine. Prof. Watts spoke about her research and the relationship between arts and social sciences. Full Keynote-presentation is also available at Versus -magazine.


Professor Phillip Vannini, Royal Roads University gave another Keynote-lecture: “Disentangling wild places”. There is a short interview with him also. Full Keynote-presentation available at Versus -magazine.



Previous Conferences 

Sociology Days, “Circulations”, March 2018. University of Eastern Finland, Joensuu.

Veera Kinnunen

Workshop: Jätteen yhteiskunta (Society of Waste) (Coordinators: Jarno Valkonen & Olli Pyyhtinen)

Paper: Elävä jäte (Living Waste), Veera Kinnunen

Heikki Huilaja

Workshop: Jätteen yhteiskunta (Society of Waste) (Coordinators: Jarno Valkonen & Olli Pyyhtinen)

Paper: Yhdyskuntajätteen rytmit, reitit ja työt. Jarno Valkonen, Heikki Huilaja.

Sociology Days, “Excess and Overflows”, March 2017. University of Tampere

Veera Kinnunen

Invited keynote-panellist “Politics of surplus, surplus of politics

Panellists: Veera Kinnunen, Anna-Kaisa Kuusisto-Arponen, Katariina Kyrölä & Tuukka Ylä-Anttila.

Opening the Bin: New perspectives on waste, culture and society from the humanities and the social sciences”. April 2017, University of Lund, Helsingborg, Sweden.

Veera Kinnunen

Paper: Cohabiting with Trash

Heikki Huilaja & Johanna Saariniemi

Session: Waste Policy. (Chair: Hervé Corvellec)

Paper: Bringing Environment Back to Waste Management: a Case Study of Waste Policy in Finnish Lapland. Jarno Valkonen, Heikki Huilaja, Johanna Saariniemi, Veera Kinnunen.

SIEF Conference March 2017, Göttingen.

BEST Poster (Veera Kinnunen & Jarno Valkonen).

Living Ethics seminar September 2017, University of Lapland.

Sociology Days, March 2015, 2016  University of Helsinki and Jyväskylä

The Autumn Colloquium of the Finnish Society for Environmental Social Science, 2015, University of Tampere.

The 8th Conference on Cultural Studies, Dec 2015, University of Oulu.

Nordic Ethnology & Folklore Conference, Aug 2015, Copenhagen University.

Living Archives seminar sept 2014, University of Malmö.